Can anyone learn magic, or do you need special hands?
Anyone with patience can learn magic. Dexterity helps for sleight of hand, but whole branches of the art, mentalism and self-working card magic among them, need almost none. What every branch needs is practice, a few honest spectators and the willingness to perform badly a few times before performing well.
How long does it take to learn magic?
A first trick that genuinely fools friends takes a fortnight of daily practice. A short, reliable set of three or four effects takes a few months. Becoming a performer people pay to see takes years, because the hard part is not the method but holding a room. Fifteen minutes a day beats a long session once a week.
Which books should a beginner start with?
For cards, The Royal Road to Card Magic by Hugard and Braue, then Roberto Giobbi's Card College. For coins, J. B. Bobo's Modern Coin Magic. For a broad course across every branch, the Tarbell Course or Mark Wilson's Complete Course in Magic. For the thinking behind a performance, Darwin Ortiz's Strong Magic and Eugene Burger's writing on presentation.
Are YouTube tutorials a good way to learn magic?
They are a good way to see a move and a poor way to learn the craft. Many tutorials expose other people's work without permission and teach the method with nothing of the presentation. Use video to check your own hands against a good performer's, then go back to a book and a club where someone will tell you what is actually wrong.
Should I join a magic club?
Yes, as soon as you have one trick you can do without thinking. In the United Kingdom, The Magic Circle in London and the independent local societies around the country; in France, the Fédération Française de Magie, of which Hugo is a member, and its regional clubs. A club gives you what no video can: people who watch you perform and say where it failed.
Is it better to learn magic or mentalism first?
Learn a little magic first. Mentalism looks simpler because there is less to do with the hands, but it stands entirely on presentation and audience management, which are the skills magic teaches you by force. Six months of card and coin magic in front of real people is the best preparation a future mentalist can have.